14 February 2014 / by Radmila Gurkova

Friday Meeting: Anticipating students problems

Developed by TEFL trainer Gabriel Messina


What is anticipating students problems and why analyze learners' linguistic production? One of the most important outcomes that we take from linguistic analysis in ESL practice is the ability to anticipate learners problems, among other reasons.
What do we analyse? At the same time teachers are analyzing meaning, form, pronunciation, function, appropriateness… any type of language interference in general.


In her presentation Analysing language and anticipating problems, CELTA trainer Jo Gakonga analyses the main reasons and benefits of analyzing learners' production and anticipating students problems. We have selected a few features of her presentation.

Let's take the example below:
I WISH I HAD MORE TIME.

What errors can we expect in it applying the above characteristics?

Meaning: problems can arise when the meaning is different from that of the learner's L1 and produces language interference.
Function: problems can arise due to grammatical rules not mastered or applied wrongly.
Pronunciation: problems can arise because of spelling and pronunciation being different, especially in languages with phonetic spelling, such as Spanish, Italian, Portuguese...
Function: the purpose of the speaker can be determinant too, for example, speculating, regretting, refusing, etc.
Appropriateness: There can be different levels of formality due to cultural differences.

This is how this principle operates at a practical level:





















 Anticipating 1
 Anticipating 2
 Anticipating 3
Anticipating 4
 Anticipating 5
 Anticipating 6

 

 


Anticipating students problems is a skill that you will develop with practice. Error analysis is related to the mother tongue intervening along with English.

In your teaching practice you will detect many common errors in Spanish learners. Here is a brief list of the most common ones which you can broaden.

 

  1. Regarding morphology:

    1. Omitting the –s of 3rd person singular of verbs, e.g. She speak English. He playtennis.

    2. Confusing he and she. Spanish people often confuse these pronouns.

    3. Wrong article usage

    4. Wrong singular/plural usage. E.g. The people are crazy. There are many mens.




 

  1. Regarding pronunciation

    1. Pronunciation of initial S + Consonant: start, stop, stadium, split, etc.

    2. V/B sounds are pronounced the same

    3. J/G sounds are hard to pronounce

    4. H sound is pronounce too guttural

    5. Past simple of regular verbs: e.g. walked pronounced as “waked”.

    6. Pronunciation of silent L in could, would, should

    7. Same pronunciation of long and short i: sheet/shit, feet / fit.

    8. Pronunciation of final T, etc.

    9. Stress and intonation. Since there are no specific rules for stress in English, Spanish learners have to learn the words with their stress. Intonation patterns are also different.




 

  1. Regarding syntax

    1. Using wrong prepositions, e.g. depends of instead of depends on

    2. Word order of adjectives, e.g. apple green instead of green apple

    3. Tense formation. Using present simple instead of present perfect, e.g. I live in Spain for five years, instead of I’ve lived / been living in Spain for 5 years.

    4. Wrong use of auxiliaries in questions. Wrong use of inversion.




 

  1. Regarding lexicon

    1. False friends of same root, e.g. grades / marks, assist / attend, etc.

    2. Preference of using one word verbs from latin roots rather than phrasal verbs. Enter=come in




Anticipating students problems is definitely the best way to avoid frustrations in learners and making the L2 acquisition process easier for your learners.

23

February 2016
You are how you think
by Paola Tanc
A lot of people often say that you are what you eat, but it really should be "you are how you think". Let me explain. My name is Paola, I was born and raised in Mexico City, meaning that Spanish is my native language. I had always been a very shy little girl, living in my perfect little bubble and having a big family meant that I didn't re...

19

February 2016
Sharing Experiences: Food
by Toby Knight
Food. I love it. We have to eat it to survive but more importantly it defines who we are, where we are from and represents countries and cultures. ESL conversations require both students and teachers sharing experiences and in my opinion there is no better topic than food. Consider this: Spain has more restaurants, bars and cafeterias than al...

18

January 2016
Building professional identity in a community of practice
by Ana Garza
When we decided to start our careers as teachers by working for someone else, we started to participate in a community of practice ...

15

January 2016
The joys and tribulations of web classes
by Rafael Olivares
It's 8:30 in the morning. Your 3 students from Valencia, Zaragoza and Barcelona are getting ready for a web class. In half an hour, they will all be enjoying their 30 minute web class with each other and their favorite teacher. No, they will not be commuting to Madrid at the speed of sound in order to be together in class by 9:00, nor will...

11

January 2016
A perfect ESL conversation
by Paola Tanc
I'd like you to look back at your past experiences as a student. What were the best memories you had about those classes?What could you do to recreate them in your classroom? Personally, my best memories are the ones where I had the most fun. When the teacher thought outside the box and did something different and challenging for a change....

08

January 2016
Teaching Taboo Subjects
by Toby Knight
When I first started teaching I found myself teaching an activity about relationships to normally out-going group of students. Less than a minute into the discussion one student announced that she did not want me to ask her any questions as she had recently ended a relationship and was too upset to talk about the subject. It was obviously an ...

18

December 2015
Eating your way through Spain
by Rafael Olivares
If you are living and working in Spain, it is more than likely that you will have heard someone utter the words: "Spain has some of the finest food in the world." And yet, many foreigners working as TEFL teachers become quickly disillusioned with Spain's gastronomic offerings. The reason behind this dissapointment lies in the difficulty of...

14

December 2015
Dealing with those difficult students
by Rob Wylie
Despite the majority of students being motivated and professional, there is always a possibility you may come across one or two “difficult” students who come to class with a negative attitude. I’m sure that as teachers we can all relate to this and have some form of experience when it comes to having to work with a person who arrives to class...

12

December 2015
What you need to ask yourself before creating ESL activities
by Paola Tanc
Creating ESL activities can sometimes be frustrating, at least that's the case in my life. I sometimes find myself in need for inspiration, so I google some conversation topics that might interest the students, or that's what I think.  I start working on the activity until I feel that it is perfect, I submit my activity and wait for the day w...

07

December 2015
ESL teachers' frustrations. Is there a way out?
by Ana Garza
Monday. 8:30 in the morning. A mixed-level group of unresponsive adult learners. Is it me? At least it’s only three of them. Or maybe that’s the problem. Is it their personalities? Perhaps it’s that they’re not interested in the activities. But everything played out so well in my mind last night… questions and answers, role-...